A reflection on 'levels' when teaching and practicing collective vocal improvisation
Throughout all these years singing, facilitating vocal improvisation and training people to lead spontaneous collective singing, I have encountered many different participants, and began to notice the challenges that separating people in 'levels' can potentially bring, especially in creating community.
I have therefore become careful of isolating 'levels', as I notice that pretty much everyone is unevenly and diversely developed in their capabilities. Especially if we consider the musical, the creative, the vocal, the interpersonal and the somatic as equally important abilities. Sometimes levels can be a good tool for isolating certain skills, but more often than not, they can create hierarchy and separation.
Also, my experiences as a learner and as a facilitator have shifted my perspective toward more holistic ways of understanding learning (beyond accumulating skills), and have shown me the huge potential for 'alchemical skill exchanges' between participants.
Of course, absolute beginners need to work together and explore a certain material in order to enter the practice and become more confident. And perhaps very advanced practitioners might benefit from the same. But the majority of people who join a training or a vocal improv session sit somewhere between these two 'levels'.
In response to that, I don't tend to isolate 'levels'. I believe that as a facilitator in the 'real world' you'll pretty much always need to work with that diversity of needs and experiences in your participants.
In Enabling Singing Villages, the training courses that I offer, I often find myself working with a wonderful mix: facilitators who need to strengthen their musicianship, seasoned improvisers who need to grow as facilitators, musicians who can already facilitate but need to develop their improvisational voices... And the list goes on.
Part of the beauty of this model is the cross-fertilisation. People can learn from each other and come out of the training with a clear sense of what it is that they have to follow through in order to become more rounded as musical facilitators and human beings.
Learning the competences to become a more rounded vocal improv facilitator alongside people radically different from you in skill set benefits everyone — it helps each person work out what they need at their particular stage of development. And it is more of a reflection of the reality in any community.
If I think of the facilitator's being (and indeed of any vocal improviser) as a flower with many 'petals', almost everyone has some petals more developed than others. But sometimes we are not yet aware of which are our areas for potential growth, nor of how to make the most of what we already have learned.
I ask myself: who am I to decide what level someone is? What's the use of someone evaluating themselves that way? How helpful is it for them to be pinned — by me or by themselves — into a certain level? And how much does this perpetuate the unpleasant experiences many of us had as young music learners (and as humans), conspiring against reclaiming our musical freedom?
I believe that the 'enemies' are universal, and they can creep in at every ‘level’: self-judgment and comparison, fear of mistakes, of being 'not enough' or 'too much' …which can fuel anxiety and tension, and prevent everyone from enjoying themselves, and delighting in that wonderful variety of experiences that is our shared humanity, creative impulse and resonance.